This week we ask whether an EET election attracts stamp duty. Proposed s 102UYD(2) requires the trustee to “confer present entitlements to shares of the income and capital of the trust in accordance with the EET nomination”, in fixed percentages totalling 100%.
In Pharmos, an instrument giving priority entitlements to income and capital vested a proprietary interest in the trust fund. In Edge, a contractual right to a future, contingent interest was an “interest” under s 2(1). Does an EET election do the same?
Come prepared to discuss:
- What does the election do? Applying Pharmos, what is the legal nature and effect of the nomination? Does it bind the trustee, or only determine how the trust is taxed?
- Is an interest created? On Edge, is the right to be made presently entitled each year an “interest”, even if future or contingent? If “capital” means corpus, is there a vesting each year?
- Does s 71 apply? Is the nomination, the notice to the Commissioner, or the annual resolution an instrument effecting or recording a declaration of trust or the creation of an interest in trust property (s 71(3)(a)(ii)–(iii), s 71(9))? If so, how is it valued under s 71(8)?
Pharmos Nominees Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Taxation [2012] SASCFC 89
Particularly [63]–[64], [67]–[69] and [71]–[74].
Edge Developments Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Taxation [2023] SASCA 88
Particularly Bleby JA at [81], [89]–[93] and [100]–[104], and Nicholson AJA (dissenting) at [126]–[129].
Stamp Duties Act 1923 (SA) s 71
Particularly s 71(3)(a), (8) and (9).
Discussion led by Adrian Cartland