Last week we looked at the excluded election trust (EET) election in the minimum tax on discretionary trusts. Our view was that it cannot work. The nomination fixes who takes the income and capital, and in what shares, “for each year of income”. A trustee that makes it gives up its continuing duty to consider every beneficiary. After Owies v JJE Nominees, that is a breach of trust. The daughter left out of the nomination has a stronger claim than the daughter in Owies, because the trustee has written down in advance that it will not consider her.

After the session, Campbell and I asked whether trust machinery could rescue the election. We want one trust estate and two trust funds. The head fund holds the property for the whole class of beneficiaries. The sub-fund holds property only for the beneficiaries named in the nomination, in the nominated shares, and the EET election is made for the sub-fund.

If that works, the Owies problem goes away. In Owies the breach was the trustee’s failure to consider beneficiaries it owed a duty to. If the sub-fund property is held only for the nominated beneficiaries, the trustee owes the other beneficiaries no duty in respect of it. The election then shuts no one out.

Keeping it to one trust estate matters, because the election is made “in respect of the trust estate”, and the trustee may make it only if:

“(a) the trust estate is a minimum tax trust; and
(b) the trust estate is in existence on 1 July 2028; …”

A sub-fund that is a separate trust is a new trust estate. It may not have existed on 1 July 2028, and its creation may be a resettlement.

Aussiegolfa is the case on sub-funds. A single DomaCom unit trust held a sub-fund for one apartment in Burwood. The Full Court held that the sub-fund was a separate trust, even though the constitution declared there was only one. The court also accepted that sub-funds can exist within a single trust. So can we build a sub-fund that is separate enough to isolate the trustee’s duties, but not so separate that it becomes a new trust estate? And if the only way to make the election work is this kind of trust machinery, what does that say about the regime?

Come prepared to discuss the following:

  • When is a sub-fund a separate trust? What did the Full Court look at to decide that the Burwood sub-fund was a separate trust? Which of those features would our sub-fund need to avoid?
  • One trust estate or two? Can the duties owed in respect of the sub-fund be confined to the nominated beneficiaries while the sub-fund stays part of the trust estate that existed on 1 July 2028?
  • Does the deed decide it? The DomaCom constitution declared “a single trust” and the court found a separate one. What would our deed need to say, and would saying it matter?
  • Which income? The nomination must account for 100% of the income of “the trust estate”. What happens to the income of the head fund?
  • Does Owies return in another place? The head fund trustee must still consider every beneficiary when it decides to put property into the sub-fund. If the sub-fund trustee keeps any discretion, does the election fetter it?
  • Which side wants which answer? In Aussiegolfa the taxpayer argued for a single trust and the Commissioner for a separate one. Here, the taxpayer needs the funds separate for trust law purposes but a single trust estate for tax purposes.

Required reading:

 

Discussion led by  Dr Campbell Rankine & Adrian Cartland &